Mabel and Fatty's Wash Day (1915) User Reviews

Elaborating the Model

[boblipton · 6/10 · 4 April 2005]

This looks like a typical flirting-in-the-park one-reeler from Keystone in this era, but this early Arbuckle-directed film shows a bit more care in plot construction than was usually taken: we are given a sense of connection and sympathy of Roscoe and Mabel, next-door neighbors, hard workers who are put upon by their spouses. Mabel's is lazy, Roscoe's gets to abuse him physically.

The gag construction is a bit thin. We are still in the world of Keystone in which speed and damage are all that are required to make it work. However, the prints are good and we get to see a little real acting by the leads. I doubt this will win any converts to Roscoe's fan club, but it isn't very long and is well done for the sub-genre.

Enjoyable short shows why Fatty and Mabel were popular...

[Doylenf · 6/10 · 16 March 2009]

There's an endearing quality about some of these old-fashioned shorts and this one from 1915 is no exception.

Mabel Normand and Fatty Arbuckle are neighbors on washing day. The simple device has both of them fed up with their annoying mates and meeting innocently on wash day when Arbuckle allows Mabel to use his wringer for her hubby's clothes. Jealousy rears its head and misunderstandings follow, especially after a day at the park involving a mix-up of purses that has the police joining in on a merry chase.

The usual blend of comedy and slapstick works well here with the park scene being the most enjoyable part of the short. Arbuckle and Normand obviously knew how to play comedy for the silents.

Not outstanding, but cute, enjoyable, and interesting

[jackmagicjck2 · 6/10 · 4 April 2005]

This was a cute little short, and an interesting one at that too. It certainly nothing outstanding. I saw this movie on Turner Classic Movies. I am someone who is very interested in film history and i have read many things on the lives of the film's two stars Mabel Normand and Fatty Arbuckle. It is very ironic how both these stars were involved with murder scandals at the same time. Mabel Normand was seen with director William Desmond Taylor just a few short minutes before he was shot dead, and her association with the womanizing director destroyed her career and she never acted again. She died of tuberculosis in 1936. Her frequent co-star Fatty Arbuckle was at around the same time involved with a similar scandal. At a party at San Fransisco's St. Francis Hotel, a young actress Virginia Rappe, a notorious party girl fainted after drinking way too much. She awoke to Fatty applying ice to her thigh and she screamed he was trying to rape her. She died a few days later. The media portrayed her as an innocent 'real life' Snow White when in reality she was anything but that. However Fatty was put on trial for her murder. Even though he was acquitted, in fact the jury later apologized to him the scandal destroyed his career as well. He died of a heart attack in 1933. The film itself is very simple, nothing really outstanding. But i must say after reading so much about these two and seeing so many still photos of them it is interesting to see the two of them in motion. They are both very cute and likable when on screen together. They have some quirky moments together such as when they are putting laundry on the clothesline and they accidentally exchanged underwear. It certainly not genius but there is just something so sweet about the two of them together. The tragedy and scandals surrounding both their lives only adds to their mystique.

Fatty and Mabel R.I.P.

Good Arbuckle/Normand Feature

[Snow Leopard · 15 November 2005]

This feature makes good use of the pairing of Mabel Normand and Roscoe Arbuckle. When they were in good form together, they could make even thin story ideas and gags look pretty good, and here they take a decent if familiar setup and make it work pretty well.

The setup has Normand's character married to a lazy, oafish husband, and Arbuckle saddled with a bossy, unpleasant wife. Things start off with the two put-upon spouses having a friendly meeting while washing clothes, and then this is followed by a sequence with all four characters in the park. The first half is the more enjoyable of the two, even though it does not have any uproarious gags. It shows the two stars at their most sympathetic, and even though the comedy is very light in itself, it takes on an added dimension because of the likable characters.

The second part features more of the kind of boisterous comedy for which Keystone movies were so well known. It's not bad either, and here too Normand and Arbuckle make the material work better than it would have on its own. But it's the gentler, domestic first half that best makes use of Mabel and Roscoe together.

A decent Arbuckle film

[planktonrules · 7/10 · 16 July 2006]

This comedy short actually has a plot--a rarity for an early Keystone film! Fatty is married to a horrid woman who browbeats him unmercifully. It seems that Fatty's wife makes him do all the work around the house! His next door neighbor is a nice lady, but her husband is the jealous type and thinks something might be going on when his wife and Fatty are outside doing laundry.

Later, both couples separately decide to go for a walk in the park---the same park that is featured in MANY Keystone films. At the park, Fatty's wife falls asleep and gives him a moment to relax. He sneaks away and meets up with his pretty neighbor and asks her to accompany him to the snack bar. But, as his wife has all the money, he sneaks back and takes her purse. When the old battleaxe wakes up a little later, she thinks her purse has been stolen and thinks the man next door did it! This is a cute comedy of errors and is HIGHLY reminiscent of a later Arbuckle film, Fatty's Chance Acquaintance (also from 1915--made only two months later). Unfortunately, in many of the early Keystone films, they used and re-used story ideas and variations on them again and again.

This flick is the sort that got "Fatty" Arbuckle into trouble later . . .

[cricket30 · 6/10 · 18 January 2014]

. . . as the Los Angeles prosecutor thought he could reach the governor's chair by persecuting Roscoe A. for capital murder (just because he gave an ailing friend an ice pack) during the THREE infamous "Tummy Rub Trials" of the early 1920s. Fatty should have known better than to portray a hen-pecked husband making nice to the wandering wife next door. This is the sort of thing they preach sermons against in church. Roscoe grew up in this country, being born in the heart of the "Bible Belt"--Smith Center, KS. What was he paying attention to during his elementary school history lessons about "Bleeding Kansas," where the Wrath of God always is just around the corner? Is it fair to say that shelling out more than $9 million to lawyers (in today's money) to avoid being executed, losing his wife, cars, and home, and having his career ruined forever (after being America's #1 star) is a SMALL PRICE TO PAY for churning out salacious material such as this 13-minute short?

Mabel and Fatty, we hardly knew ye

[lee_eisenberg · 6/10 · 28 October 2018]

Big stars in their time, Mabel Normand and Fatty Arbuckle saw their careers ruined by scandals, and they died a few years later. One of their movies was 1915's "Mabel and Fatty's Wash Day", depicting a series of goofs as the two attempt to wash and dry their clothes. Most of the movies from cinema's infancy were shorts with simple plots. This is a typical enjoyable short.

I wonder what direction Normand's and Arbuckle's careers would've taken had they not got ruined.

Fun Short

[Michael_Elliott · 10 March 2008]

Mabel and Fatty's Wash Day (1915)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

Good-hearted and fun one-reeler from Keystone has a wife (Mabel Normand) slaving away at laundry while her worthless husband sleeps. Their neighbor (Roscoe 'Fatty' Arbuckle) finds himself doing laundry for a worthless wife. Soon Fatty and Mabel meet up for some fun, which of course doesn't sit well with their "others." MABEL AND FATTY'S WASH DAY certainly isn't the best film that the team made together but there are enough small laughs to make it worth sitting through. There are some funny moments including the husband going off on Fatty early in the picture as well as another scene at the end when the husband is mistaken for a thief. The majority of the smiles come from the charm of Arbuckle who does a very good job here in regards to the acting. I thought he made for a very sympathetic character and at least made you feel for him and laugh. Normand is also good in her role even though she isn't given as much to do. The film runs at a very good pace as the director (Arbuckle) manages to keep everything flowing well.