First, Al Pacino deserves an Emmy nomination. So does Saul Rubinek and Carol Kane. They are real flesh and blood characters with performances that are sensitive, nuanced, powerful.
Second, the below review was after 2-3 episodes. I almost stopped watching, but the compelling scenes kept me in, like that final shot on the 18th hole that is perfect after a lousy golf game...and it keeps you coming back. This show gets better, and I think it's because producers realized they ROYALLY screwed up in the first 2-3 episodes. They lost a critical chunk of audience because of it. What began as truly immature filmmaking evolves into some truly powerful stuff, from cartoonish nonsense to deeply moving and dramatic and electric filmmaking. My original review:
Well, after the first episode or two, so far, this is a MASSIVE failure in execution. I am stunned by the EPIC miscalculation by producers that 1) a story about Nazi hunters in America should be told in this Tarantino-wannabe style, while WILDLY lacking his deft touch when mingling humor with unimaginable tragedy, 2) this - so-far - Tarantino knock-off wouldn't be seen as a total rip-off instead, and 3) camp and silliness and comic book characters and characterizations have ANY place in a series about the hunt for guys that used the skin of Jews for lampshades, who used bulldozers to push stacks of ex-human beings, starved to death, into pits, who enjoyed raping, torturing, experimenting on little Jewish boys and girls, and well, the list goes on and on. Tarantino's "Inglourious Basterds" achieved something NO ONE else can do right now, and his take on the subject of Jews recruited into the Nazi-killing business , while using some highly stylized techniques sprinkled with dark humor, NEVER, EVER approached the non-justified silliness we see in "The Hunters", and NEVER, EVER let you forget that we are talking about horrifically scarred Jews who've set about eradicating the the greatest monsters our species has ever produced. Now, perhaps it'll get better - it has to - but only if it stops trying to be something it can never be.
Pacino is WONDERFUL, of course, and some of the other older actors (Carol Kane, Saul Rubinek, Lena Olin) support him well, but the rest of the cast has much to prove. And while this show is largely a hot mess, there are compelling scenes, unfortunately divided by connective tissue that should be aggressively excised.
The soundtrack is often B-movie horror, the direction is heavy-handed and renders critical characters in 2D at best, and MY GOODNESS, when the main characters break out in dance to Saturday Night Fever at Coney Island...and then a bunch of random people start breaking out ion carefully choreographed dance as if we're now in "musical" mode, it's just ridiculous.
Here is just one of many examples of the dumb mistakes writer David Weil and executive producer Jordan Peele make:
There is a scene where Nazi's play chess on a large field using Jewish prisoners as chess pieces. When the piece is lost, the Jew is shot dead and hauled away. Never happened. Weil's explanation: He wanted to convey a "representational truth", i.e., convey just how brutal and callous and sadistic the Nazi's were. Are you effen kidding me?!? What, the LITERAL truth isn't brutal enough?!?
Weil rails against revisionist narratives that whitewash Nazi crimes....while he offers his own anti-Nazi revisionist history which, in fact, is precisely what those Nazi revisionists lie in wait for.
Finally, there really were and are Jewish Nazi hunters. This often flippant treatment of this topic thoroughly disrespects them all and the unimaginable pain they endured.
1 out of 6 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends