In Desmond's vision, Charlie, with a mostly clean shirt, is hit by an arrow in the throat. However, it is obvious that the bloodstain which would have been caused by the bleeding on the shirt was there prior to the actual penetration.
Although the crates say 1989, the labels on the wine say 1995.
The photo of Brother Campbell and Ms. Hawkins, sitting in a framed photo on his desk, is very obviously Photoshopped.