Nurse Lila Nolan returns home to Cabot Cove after working in Boston for a few years. Seth Hazlett is quite close to Lila and even set up a college fund for her to attend Nursing school. Now back home, Lila is working as a home care nurse looking after the elderly Horace Gibbs who dies not long after she starts caring for him. Gibbs' daughter starts bothering Sheriff Metzger to investigate her father's death and, out of courtesy, he looks into Lila's background. In the interim, Lila begins to care for Jessica's good friend Maggie Saunders but when she too dies, Lila is arrested. When the Sheriff learns that Lila has lost several elderly patients it looks quite bleak for Lila. Jessica, however, thinks the young woman is innocent and sets a trap to get the real killer.
—garykmcd