The Violation of Sarah McDavid (TV Movie 1981) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Sarah's education has just begun
petershelleyau18 November 2002
Patty Duke is the title character, an English school teacher at Benjamin Harrison High School who is raped in her classroom. The principal Walter Keys (Ned Beatty) tries to dissuade Sarah from reporting the rape to the police, to also conceal other violence that is occuring in the school. But Sarah thinks otherwise.

Duke looks chubby here, and her spectacles give way to contact lenses just before her attack, so that one lens can infect her right eye and disfigure her for the remainder of the film. Her spinsterish schoolmarm prefigures Duke's transition into character parts, however she is funny in the way she uses her still working eyes when she tells her students how her boyfriend Eddie (James Sloyan) is not dull `believe me'.

The teleplay by Lois and Arnold Peyser, based on a story by the Peysers and Joan Marks, uses this school's incidents as a jumping off point for the trend of teachers being harmed in public schools and school beatings, undermined by Keys' fearful realism that security measures deprive the academic program of funding. The high school's established emergency alarms that Sarah is shown when she joins the staff are a surprise to her, an indication of prior problems, though we see how easily they are taken for granted when Sarah isn't rescued during her attack. The Peysers have one non-school laugh line - when Sarah is seen jogging she is told `One day they're gonna find out jogging is bad for you', to which she replies `First they gotta find out it's bad for mice'. The narrative slows down once Sarah's gift for teaching is established, as if the thing we wait for is her attack, and and there is a similar pauses while Sarah recuperates. There are flashbacks to the rape when she returns to the same room, an indication that the trauma will affect her future, though Sarah's decision seems to be made prematurely.

Director John Llewellyn Moxey supplies some swift edits to jump start the narrative now and again, and Sloyan gives a good yell in response to news of the rape. The denouement is interesting for it's personal small triumph as opposed to a world scale which is generally the case in this kind of material made for television in the decade later.
19 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Easy to see why Astin picked this script...but do we really want to see Patty Duke in this part?
moonspinner5527 May 2024
Warning: Spoilers
With a title that practically screams "Television Movie!", we see substitute-turned-full-time teacher Patty Duke Astin climbing the steps of the local high school on her first big day (it's just an ordinary-seeming high school, yet she exclaims to the custodian, "It's really something, isn't it?"). What Astin's Sarah McDavid doesn't know is, the school has a high crime rate--with all incidents gone unreported once the fat-cat Dean (Ned Beatty) manages to sweep every bit of scandal under the proverbial rug. This happens to Sarah too, after she's beaten and raped by an outsider during Open House (she rings her classroom's alarm several times, with no answer). Written by committee (or, in this case, Lois Peyser and Arnold Peyser from a treatment by the Peysers and Joan Maeks), nothing in "Violation" feels true. Not Sarah's hesitancy in coming forward, not her sudden shift towards "wave-maker", not the school's handling of the event, and certainly not Sarah's press conference at the finale. The Dean tells Sarah after she makes her impassioned plea for school security, "This is going to take money away from getting new textbooks!" There is no follow-up to Sarah's visit to the police station--and apparently no chance of ever catching the creep who raped her. The goal here was to get Patty Duke Astin up on a soapbox, possibly to qualify her for an Emmy nomination. But any actress could have played this part...and do we really want to see Patty Duke play it?
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed