A nifty whodunit for ace detective Philo Vance, this time played by Paul Lukas. William Powell was asked to continue the role (last played in THE KENNEL MURDER CASE), but obviously caught up in the THIN MAN and didn't want to confuse both characters.
That said, MGM borrowed from the Thin Man mystique and welcomed the competition, developing Philo Vance into more of a "sociable" detective. In fact, the studio attempted to showcase Lukas and co-star Rosalind Russell against Powell and Myrna Loy. The mystery, well written by the team of Edgar Allen Woolf and Florence Ryerson (who wrote the screen version of the WIZARD OF OZ), is about a devious killer with lots of poison, attempting to kill socialite Lynn Llewellyn (Donald Cook) at his uncle's casino and finally succeeding in doing in his wife, played by popular MGM actress Louise Henry. Bottom line, a family member may be the killer -- but who?
Debonaire Paul Lukas is quite good as Vance, although critics weren't too keen about his Hungarian accent. The supporting cast is excellent, lead by versatile Alison Skipworth (on loan from Paramount Pictures), playing matron Priscilla Llewellyn, young Rosalind Russell as Doris, also Eric Blore, pretty Isabel Jewell and silent screen comedian Louise Fazenda (married to producer Hal B. Wallis) as Becky. Not to miss former Three Stooges alumnus Ted Healy as the police sergeant.
By midway, can you guess whodunit?
Edwin L. Marin did an excellent job of directing, next to handle the GARDEN MURDER CASE, starring Edmund Lowe as Philo Vance opposite Virginia Bruce. The Vance mysteries were exceptional, this being the eighth in the film series, MGM buying up the books and making author S. S. Van Dine quite wealthy. However, the THIN MAN (or rather William Powell) was tough competition to beat.
Always on remastered dvd and thanks to TCM for rerunning this gem that hasn't been on tv for decades.
That said, MGM borrowed from the Thin Man mystique and welcomed the competition, developing Philo Vance into more of a "sociable" detective. In fact, the studio attempted to showcase Lukas and co-star Rosalind Russell against Powell and Myrna Loy. The mystery, well written by the team of Edgar Allen Woolf and Florence Ryerson (who wrote the screen version of the WIZARD OF OZ), is about a devious killer with lots of poison, attempting to kill socialite Lynn Llewellyn (Donald Cook) at his uncle's casino and finally succeeding in doing in his wife, played by popular MGM actress Louise Henry. Bottom line, a family member may be the killer -- but who?
Debonaire Paul Lukas is quite good as Vance, although critics weren't too keen about his Hungarian accent. The supporting cast is excellent, lead by versatile Alison Skipworth (on loan from Paramount Pictures), playing matron Priscilla Llewellyn, young Rosalind Russell as Doris, also Eric Blore, pretty Isabel Jewell and silent screen comedian Louise Fazenda (married to producer Hal B. Wallis) as Becky. Not to miss former Three Stooges alumnus Ted Healy as the police sergeant.
By midway, can you guess whodunit?
Edwin L. Marin did an excellent job of directing, next to handle the GARDEN MURDER CASE, starring Edmund Lowe as Philo Vance opposite Virginia Bruce. The Vance mysteries were exceptional, this being the eighth in the film series, MGM buying up the books and making author S. S. Van Dine quite wealthy. However, the THIN MAN (or rather William Powell) was tough competition to beat.
Always on remastered dvd and thanks to TCM for rerunning this gem that hasn't been on tv for decades.
Tell Your Friends