Our Idiot Brother is an ensemble comedy about a brother who unexpectedly comes back into the lives of three New York sisters. Ned, played by Paul Rudd, is not exactly an idiot, but more like a happy-go-lucky puppy who sometimes pees on the carpet. Ned only sees the good in people and believes that if you give others the benefit of the doubt, things will work out for the better. Unfortunately for Ned, he lives in the real world and not everyone is the Honest-Abe Ned embodies.
The movie starts off with Ned being arrested for selling Marijuana to a officer on duty, who takes advantage of Ned's generous nature by telling him he's been going through some tough times. After being released from prison for good behavior Ned returns home to a co- op biodynamic farm only to learn that his long term hippie girlfriend (Kathryn Hahn) has replaced him with a new boyfriend, Billy played by T.J. Miller. Not only is she kicking Ned out the farm but she's also decided to keep Ned's best friend in the world, a golden retriever by the name of Willie Nelson.
With only a backpack to his name Ned moves back in with his family which consists of his mother and three sisters: Liz (Emily Mortimer) the busy mother of two who is married to an documentary filmmaker, Miranda (Elizabeth Banks) the career oriented journalist, and Natalie (Zooey Deschanel) the bisexual artist - slash - comedian. Ned moves from one sister's home to the next as his welcome is quickly depleted by Ned's inability to adapt his sisters' Type A personalities. Ned's just not used to the double faced lives of other people. His innocence doesn't allow him to keep track of what's a secret and what's not. Ned has the strange ability to reveal the darker sides of those around him, revealing truths that many would rather not acknowledge. Ned acts as the catalyst to disrupt everyone else's shallow lives so that they may live a truer and more loving existence. "Ignorance is bliss" is obviously a strong theme in this film.
The cast for the film is very dynamic with plenty of talent to hold the scenes together. However some of the sisters never quite garner enough sympathy from the audience. They are all so self absorbed that when they blame their problems on Ned it simply adds for the viewer's dislike for the characters. Our Idiot Brother is primarily about family but great family feuding films have great moments of forgiveness. This film has one of those moments but for some reason the forgiveness feels like there wasn't much of a struggle. The reason for this is there's simply no reason to hate such a simple and loving character. Yes, Ned can be a little blind to things going on around him but overall the anger towards Ned from his sisters just makes them look jealous of his honesty.
As for Ned you never really know where he's supposed to be going in the film. It is somewhat set up that he has dreams of living back on the farm or perhaps regaining his long lost dog but those desires are fairly weightless in the context of a movie. For this reason the film fails to be anything more than a slightly bigger version of your family sitcom episode. You'll still laugh, but tomorrow you won't remember why it was it was so funny.
This Film might not be for you if:
-You don't like Paul Rudd's charm
The movie starts off with Ned being arrested for selling Marijuana to a officer on duty, who takes advantage of Ned's generous nature by telling him he's been going through some tough times. After being released from prison for good behavior Ned returns home to a co- op biodynamic farm only to learn that his long term hippie girlfriend (Kathryn Hahn) has replaced him with a new boyfriend, Billy played by T.J. Miller. Not only is she kicking Ned out the farm but she's also decided to keep Ned's best friend in the world, a golden retriever by the name of Willie Nelson.
With only a backpack to his name Ned moves back in with his family which consists of his mother and three sisters: Liz (Emily Mortimer) the busy mother of two who is married to an documentary filmmaker, Miranda (Elizabeth Banks) the career oriented journalist, and Natalie (Zooey Deschanel) the bisexual artist - slash - comedian. Ned moves from one sister's home to the next as his welcome is quickly depleted by Ned's inability to adapt his sisters' Type A personalities. Ned's just not used to the double faced lives of other people. His innocence doesn't allow him to keep track of what's a secret and what's not. Ned has the strange ability to reveal the darker sides of those around him, revealing truths that many would rather not acknowledge. Ned acts as the catalyst to disrupt everyone else's shallow lives so that they may live a truer and more loving existence. "Ignorance is bliss" is obviously a strong theme in this film.
The cast for the film is very dynamic with plenty of talent to hold the scenes together. However some of the sisters never quite garner enough sympathy from the audience. They are all so self absorbed that when they blame their problems on Ned it simply adds for the viewer's dislike for the characters. Our Idiot Brother is primarily about family but great family feuding films have great moments of forgiveness. This film has one of those moments but for some reason the forgiveness feels like there wasn't much of a struggle. The reason for this is there's simply no reason to hate such a simple and loving character. Yes, Ned can be a little blind to things going on around him but overall the anger towards Ned from his sisters just makes them look jealous of his honesty.
As for Ned you never really know where he's supposed to be going in the film. It is somewhat set up that he has dreams of living back on the farm or perhaps regaining his long lost dog but those desires are fairly weightless in the context of a movie. For this reason the film fails to be anything more than a slightly bigger version of your family sitcom episode. You'll still laugh, but tomorrow you won't remember why it was it was so funny.
This Film might not be for you if:
-You don't like Paul Rudd's charm
Tell Your Friends