"WatchMojo" Top 10 Out-of-Genre TV Episodes (TV Episode 2015)
"The Nightman Cometh" gets an honorable mention."WatchMojo" Top 10 Best It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia Episodes (TV Episode 2017)
"The Nightman Cometh" is #1."WatchMojo" Top 10 Awkward Moments in It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia (TV Episode 2019)
Charlie Proposes to the Waitress gets an honorable mention."WatchMojo" Another Top 10 Out-of-Genre TV Episodes (TV Episode 2019)
"The Nightman Cometh" is #4."MsMojo" Top 10 Musical Episodes of Non-Musical TV Shows (TV Episode 2021)
"The Nightman Cometh" gets an honorable mention.
Postal 2 (Video Game 2003)
Achievement "Gotta pay the Troll Toll"."The Cinema Snob" Troll (TV Episode 2009)
"Harry Potter and the Toll Troll of the Boy's Soul.""It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia" Thunder Gun Express (TV Episode 2011)
Frank tells the tour group that he was in a musical that Charlie wrote"AniMat's Crazy Cartoon Cast" Popeye's NOT Dead (Podcast Episode 2020)
Brought up in discussion."AniMat's Crazy Cartoon Cast" Top 5 Animation News of 2020 (Podcast Episode 2021)
"It's a jukebox musical and we intend for it to be cheap as hell like The Nightman Cometh..."
The Iceman Cometh (1973)
Title ReferenceThe Princess Bride (1987)
Dee tells Charlie that he keeps using a word he seems to not know the meaning of.
The Nightman Cometh Live! (Video 2009)
A filmed play